Tuesday, January 3, 2012

I love you thiiiiiiis much: a (not very) professional critique of Scotty McReery's "I Love you This Big"

                This has been a long time coming, but this is something I want to rant about, if only to flex my creative muscles when it comes to disses. 
                One lovely day, my girlfriend and I decided to go to a Mediterranean restaurant for lunch.  It was absolutely wonderful.  The atmosphere was warm, dark and cozy, the service was some of the friendliest I’ve seen, and the food was to die for and prepared perfectly.  The mood stopped dead still when a certain pop song, a successful pop song came in over the speakers.  This song made us laugh harder than most joke songs we’ve heard.  There were tears in our eyes.  Since then, this song has become a running joke for us.
                There is a song called (I kid you not) “I Love You This Big” by a singer named Scotty McCreery, who is apparently the winner for season thirteen million of American idol, and whose last name I seem to be unable to spell correctly the first time throughout the entirety of my writing this.  This song hit number 11 on the Billboard 100, and number 15 on the Billboard country songs list.  This song was pretty darn successful.
                Let me explain to you why this song is stupid.Publish Post
                The tone of this song is the epitome of a love song that’s trying to appeal to both country and pop music listeners; it has weeping steel guitars, a singer with a heavy accent to add to its country twang, while it is absolutely saccharine and meaningless enough to appeal to pop music listeners with all sorts of cheesy pop lines, two short versus and an equally short chorus.
                Scotty McCreery is 18 years old, and has a face that makes him look like he’s fifteen, but has a very deep, throaty singing voice.  The one clever part about this song is they play on this, acknowledging the fact that he’s young but mature.  The main point of this song is that Scotty acknowledges that he knows he’s young and inexperienced, but damn it, he’s mature enough to know what love is, random girl that he has the hots for!
                Here’s the kicker, though: He goes on to say that he doesn’t know how to describe love, and he’s not too good with words, but you need to trust him and know that he knows how to love.  Then the chorus kicks in, the guitar starts weeping even louder, and in order to prove that he’s wise beyond his years, Scotty belts out the heartstring-tugging line “I love you this big!”  He even holds out his arms, to show this girl just how much this big is.
                Congratulations, dude.  You fail.  You are officially not going to hit that.  With a single line, you have completely destroyed any chance you had to convince this person that you are a mature, responsible adult that can love her tender and all that jazz. 
            He tries to recover from the staggering childishness of that line.  God help him, he tries.  He follows up with “Eyes have never seen this big.”  That’s kind of romantic, but you are already a lost cause.  He continues to muse, “No one’s ever dreamed this big, and I’ll spend the rest of my life explaining what words cannot describe.”
            Okay man, that was actually pretty good.  It’s going to be close, but you’ve nearly covered up that last mistake.  You’re almost there.  You’ve nearly climbed out of that hole, and convinced her that maybe she was wrong about you, and you were just saying that because you really liked her, and you were just spurting it out awkwardly.  But no, Scotty, you’ve got something else going on in your head, now.  You decide that she just didn’t get it.  You decide that no matter what she thinks, that line is meaningful as hell.  You are a poet, damn it, and how dare she not see the beauty of that line.  If you just say it a second time, then she’ll see!  Then she’ll know your brilliance! 
            Because you see, after that romantic schmaltz that amounts to “I can’t even describe it,” he decides that he still needs to get his point across, and repeats a wailing, “I love you this big!”
At this point, the girl is just sighing, rolling her eyes, and trying definitely to make eye contact with any of her friends around in desperation.  It is to no avail, because he just keeps going, and any respect she had for him is dead and gone.
There is another verse to this song, full of romantic crooning about how much he loves her, saying things like he loves her “to the moon and back,” and “higher than the pines,” but this is clearly out of desperation because he realizes he’s losing her.  He can’t buy her a drink, either, because he’s not 21!  He finishes it by repeating that he loves her thiiiiiiiis muuuch a couple of times, and the song comes to an end.
            What else can I say?  It doesn’t work.  The song is so full of stereotypical lines about how much he loves her that it hinges on the fact that the line “I love you this big” is romantic, and not at all something a six-year-old would tell to his teacher.  It’s not romantic.  When the point of this song is “I’m grown up enough to love you (which means I’m grown up enough to bone you),” you need something more mature as the hook and title of your song.  This might have worked if you had a more mature singer behind the helm, but even though Scotty has a baritone voice he lookseighteen.  This song proves he’s not ready for a relationship, and most likely should not reproduce.  It’s a good thing that if he uses lines like that, he’s not going to have the opportunity anytime soon.

No comments:

Post a Comment